Paper Review Form

Reviewer:

Paper Title:

Authors:

1.CATEGORY

Within the scope of the Conference:
Please select...YesNo

Summary type:
Please select...ScientificApplication-oriented

2. SUMMARY EVALUATION

Please use the scale from 0 (poor) to 5 (excellent)

Originality:
Please select...0(poor)12345(excellent)

Technical / scientific value:
Please select...0(poor)12345(excellent)

Clarity and suitability:
Please select...0(poor)12345(excellent)

Global evaluation:
Please select...0(poor)12345(excellent)

3. REVIEWER’S EXPERTISE

Give yourself a rating:
Please select...expert in areafamiliarsomewhat familiarnot familiar with topic – can review for general interest

4. RECOMMENDATIONS

The paper should be:
Please select...AcceptedAccepted with minor changesConditionally accepted with major changesRejected

If accepted the paper should be presented as:
Please select...OralPoster

5. COMMENTS TO THE AUTHORS

If rejected, the reviewer must state the reasons clearly and explicitly.
If accepted, suggestions to authors for improvement should be given.